Like this blog on facebook

Saturday 24 March 2012

The Environmental Hypocrisy


The reactor plant under construction at Kudankulam
Do you know without whom the world would be better? My answer to this question would be environmental activists. These peculiar breed of humans do not believe in letting the system work. Though they often work for environmental causes but most of the time their work is not inspired by belief in cause rather is a search for importance in a world which can run perfectly well without them. Their plan of action consists of finding anything worth protesting on and then misleading the innocent to join their madness. I am frustrated by their acts of hypocrisy especially when it comes down to energy.

These activists are the people who fill in our books with environmental need for non exhaustible resources; they tell us how the potential of our Himalayan Rivers are yet to be tapped. Then the go and start the Tehri dam agitation, the Narmada bachao movement, and the Save Ganga campaigns. I do believe that they are justified in their fears about the environmental costs of the projects and the resettlement of people but is it something that should come at the cost of national development?

Yes wildlife was lost when Tehri dam was constructed but then read about Itaipu and find out how little is the loss when compared to the Brazilian project. Still not ready to bear the environmental cost? All right maybe we will switch to some other form of energy with less environmental impact. Well I think even the government would agree... but hey do the activists agree? News flash: no they don’t and we have a Kudankulam at hand. This time they protest over the risk of an accident, a Fukushima or Chernobyl!

Protesters outside the Kudankulam project site
Now I would like to ask them should we stop building sky scrapers just because they may fall in a massive theoretically possible earthquake. If that be the case let us build huts in the future. Now we can’t even do that can we? Otherwise they will call us slum dwellers and cite India as poor. They always tend to argue that there are  alternatives but when you go for the alternative you end up with them citing another problem. I think I’ll mention all the energy resources and the problems they associate with them.


Resources                   Problems

Hydro power            Loss of wildlife, displacement of mass population, safety of dams.
Thermal power         Air pollution, depletion of coal, health issues.
Nuclear power          Nuclear safety, waste disposal problems.
Wind energy            Now this one is interesting. Apparently looking at the shadow cast by the fan of a windmill for a long time can drive people crazy. The bird and bat death, and a mysterious health problems termed wind-turbine syndrome also occur due to windmills.
Solar energy            Solar panels consist of toxic materials, electronic waste disposal problems, not to mention the huge cost-efficiency deficit.
Geothermal energy    As of now not sufficient to run a country. Also the technology is still far away in a land not known to man.
Tidal energy             Anchors destroy ocean bed ecosystems, disrupt fish migration routes, also there are limited places to install such projects.
Bio-gas                   Methane is a very high grade green house gas. There are safety concerns and limited production issues and if you are seriously thinking of running industries on bio-gas then imagine the number of cattle required to generate so much of feces.

Conclusion: If environmentalists had their way we would be living in dark ages. I understand all your concerns but you need to understand mine. We have to get rid of our dependence on coal and we need hydro electricity and nuclear electricity to fill in the gap. Then we may phase in other forms of energy production once problems related with them are sorted out. Even the microphones that you use to shout slogans against the government require electricity (not to mention they cause noise pollution). So either live in a house without any electric appliances or stop misleading the people and cut the crap!

Please do not mind the informal use of language.

Further reading:

No comments:

Post a Comment